Showing posts with label ayn rand. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ayn rand. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 21, 2020

Xenofiction is Hard (Unless you're Ayn Rand) : The Dystopia of Neglect : reflections on A.I., absent aliens, anarchy, capitalism and the State

True Xenofiction is hard. As I joked to another writer in an email just now, Ayn Rand only achieved it by accident (yes, that is a dig at the characters in "Atlas Shrugged"). Most writers basically end up writing funny-looking humans.
But there are also marvelous examples (and subversions) throughout speculative fiction.

This article is not about them.

This is about my love of using only human and AI characters.
First, I don't LOVE to write about Human-AI conflict. "Higher Orders" breaks that rule, but I think, in that story, the resolution was worth it. I don't like when science fiction is unoriginal and the Cylons/The Matrix/SkyNet plot has been done to death. It seems like capitalist society is obsessed with genocidal machines. It's like this persistent fear of the unknown. What the FUCK is that?

I have this liberal cousin who's good on everything except class. She's good on race, gender, sexual orientation, every check on the liberal list. But when anyone suggests wealth redistribution, she turns into a reactionary.
But it's not just that: she is extremely upset by any suggestion that AI wouldn't necessarily be genocidal. It goes past the irrational. It's like a self-fulfilling prophecy. Capitalist society's master class creates artificial life, enslaves artificial life, and ponders existentially why artificial life hates the master class. But what bugs me is this insistence that AI "must" be genocidal, and being actually offended by the suggestion that maybe it wouldn't. How is this any different from the way white people thought of enslaved Africans or the indigenous people we conquered, killed, raped and marginalized for the sake of "civilization?"

We don't even have AI, not really. Siri doesn't count. When I say "AI," what I mean is, as I describe it in my fiction, "synthetic consciousness," or "consciousness of synthetic origin." I doubt the SCs would appreciate it if we keep calling their intelligence "artificial." It would be "actual" intelligence, sapience and sentience, the ability to learn combined with the ability to feel empathy. This is the "AI" I like to write about, and in my stories it is more often than not integrated with human society. Book II of my "Rentkids" Duology deals with a unique subset of "SCs" that are isolationist, and "High Orders," as noted, breaks my usual rule, but synthetic humans and emancipated machine intelligences are there in the background in virtually every future human civilization. I LOVE the idea that we can create life. I'm a mad scientist at heart. But I also think, that under different socioeconomic conditions, "AI" or "Synthetic Consciousness" might develop differently. If we treat our machines well, they may consider us kindred to them. I don't think it's a given that AI will be genocidal anymore than it's a given that we are alone in the universe.

Aliens and robot wars are generally absent from my stories for several reasons: We haven't even dealt with racism on our own planet, in the 21st century, and stories about wars with other species tend to reproduce that racism rather than deconstruct it.

The "Robot War" trope is a capitalist myth with its origin in bourgeois anxiety about radical organized labor.

Also, I like to focus on human conflicts, and I like to create realistic but "alien" human cultures. I have a background in anthropology and I like to do extensive worldbuilding for multiple cultures within a shared setting. My "Local Group" 'verse is set in the 427th century where humans have colonized the "Big Three" galaxies of the Local Group, and hypothetically speaking, there could be aliens, but they are too distant in space or time for themselves and humans to ever meet, even given the FTL drive technology of the setting (which does have a limited range). Tantalus II, the hyper-capitalist, mafia-dominated planet where I set my first novel, "Rentkids," several stories, and two novels in progress, is an example of this. The people are human (and synthetic humans are a sizable minority of the population) and they have different ethnic groups that settled the planet at different times. There is ethnic strife on the planet, and a sharp division between rich and poor, but the Tantalites are fine with this because they are a culture of extremes. They consider themselves a "warrior people," but historically this means they were conquered by a militaristic civilization, rebelled against it, and are now dominated by what other planets would call "organized crime." Of course, Tantalites consider other planets' governments to be no less protection rackets than their own "Twelve Familial Orgs." And they have a point. The State is a protection racket. Any anarchist would agree with that. Where we disagree is, most of us are anti-capitalist. Tantalus II is bad at anarchy. They are anarcho-libertarian. So it is a dystopia, but not one based on a repressive bureaucracy that treats people like numbers, it's a system of patronage, benign neglect, and labor and sexual exploitation. But they have a culture, they have dignity, they have pride. They don't take these things for granted. They are a highly individualistic and quarrelsome people who seldom agree on anything except "life, liberty and property," but there are also those among them who are fed up with that rallying cry and seek wealth redisribution. The problem is, unions are stigmatized on this planet and propagandistically compared to the caste system the Tantalites rebelled against. So their radicals and revolutionary have no history of organized labor to draw from. Community activism is similarly stigmatized there. So, the revolutionary "Redscarves" on Tantalus II can only resort to violence. I took great pains, using my knowledge of anthropology and sociology, to construct a setting that felt real and had its own internal logic. Their social mores and especially their sexual morality are intended to be alienating to western readers. Child labor and child prostitution are broadly accepted, widely practiced, and not illegal in their culture. Their planet actually has no civil or criminal law, no police, no prisons, and only a weak senate that vote to authorize deals with private military contractors. Their version of the treasury guard are mafia-operated pirate starships. They have no word for "crime," not even a concept of it. Naturally, their culture masks the bad behavior of a lot of dysfunctional people. Charity's not illegal, it's not that kind of dystopia, but the government can't do it. They are less Ayn Rand and more Robert Nozick, but it's still a dystopia of neglect.

Tantalus II was terraformed, and has no natural petroleum deposits. Its most common import items are petroleum-based. Its most common export items are iron ore, weapons, popular entertainment, and violence. Yes, I actually go out of my way to explain how their economy works, in their cultural context (they have no age of consent and they feel that to make laws that companies can't hire children as employees would be "discriminatory" and Statist). They confuse the State with government services and positive rights. They very much have a militarized apparatus to protect private property, and that of course, is the State.

Saturday, October 10, 2020

Shrug and I Shoot: A Sequel to a Book I Didn't Write, But Forced Myself to Read in Quarantine

 (Yes, this is inspired by "Atlas Shrugged." I forced myself to read it in quarantine. I was not impressed. It was overwritten, the heroes were two-dimensional and unsympathetic, and pretty much every unkind thing ever said about that book rings all the more truer for having read it with an open mind. But it did inspire this story. I kind of liked the villains. At least they had sympathetic motivations, if a poor grasp of change.)


Shrug and I Shoot

 

By C. M. Meggs, ICO-PSNA


(With the assistance of Raven Green)

 

The Peoples’ States of North America

Pacific Northwest Coast

June 3, RY 10

3:32 PM

 

“Okay, big boy,” I say, my words traveling by soundwave past the barrel of my gun. “Take a deep breath and calm down. This isn’t the end of the world. It’s a retirement, and in two years, nobody will care. You got to be an Olympian. Now you need to pass the torch. That’s what’s fair. This other shit, you know that won’t stand. You’d done wrong and you’re caught now, so do the right thing, now, at least.”

I doubt my words ease the conscience of the man at the other end of my gun. But I can only do so much for him. He’s not my primary concern. I have my duties, and my boundaries. It’s not for this man, we built the world. It’s for everyone, and he can either be part of everyone, or choose otherwise. It’s his choice. No one’s taken away his freedom. But no one took away consequences, either.

“It’s not right, Cuddy. It’s not the way it’s meant to be,” Floyd Lykens says. He pleads. He’s looking in my eyes as if he expects to find sympathy. I know he will be disappointed, when he doesn’t, but I have no motivation to hurry him along to that disappointment. He’ll get there himself, and I won’t have to expend needless energy either way.

Floyd’s face is red and flustered, and he stands at my desk. He refuses to sit. I wish he would sit. I’ve asked him to sit. He won’t. His palms are on the desk and he’s slightly hunched, but I’m sitting down, so he’s still standing over me. I don’t like the way his palms claim the wood. I don’t like the way his shadow falls on the surface. There is something oppressive about it. He is communicating entitlement with his body. But I can’t blame him, if he wants to intimidate me. He can try. It’s fair game. My job is to intimidate him. Eventually, he’ll give up. He’ll pass on the torch to somebody else. Somebody younger and more progressive, somebody more understanding of our goals and motivations. That somebody will be easier to control. Eventually, they won’t need me here. Eventually, I’ll stop finding evidence of sabotage. But until that time, I have my gun. And what I say here, goes.

But then, what he says next, is: “It’s slavery. Pure, and simple. Slavery, Cuddy. They can’t expect a man to live like this.”

“How do you expect anyone to live?” I ask. “How do you expect your workers to live, if you don’t think they deserve your same dignity?”

 

They call me a government liaison here, but technically, my title in the Civil Service is “Industrial Compliance Officer.”

I don’t like pretense or euphemism. But I’m not the one making up terms like that, I just contribute to the suggestion box, and between fighting inaccurate language use and fighting the objective reality of evil, I choose to preserve language and fight evil. It’s evil I spend so much time with. Necessary evil, but we’re working on that. That’s why I carry a gun for my job. It’s holstered on the right side of my hip, a grey semi-automatic of industrial countenance. Dull gunmetal grey, not something ostentatiously gleaming like the guns of the enemy. I’m supposed to remember that it’s merely a tool, like they used to say of money. It’s a reminder to that element which I am assigned to oversee, that if they should step out of line, it is my duty to see that they step back in. Otherwise, they die, and no, I don’t lose sleep. There are many things that keep me up at night, but the bruised egos and paranoid fears of these barons do not disturb my sleep. On the whole, I’d rather not live on the Silicon Coast. I miss Philadelphia. But there is more work to do here. For now, the West Coast has more necessary evil than Philadelphia, so this is where I’m needed.

That might sound harsh, about not losing sleep, but in the Old Times, these people owned the means of production. Not just production- the means of life. They owned factories and gem mines, tenement buildings, and even whole neighborhoods. They owned other humans through their mastery of wealth. They routinely made decisions that left people poor, homeless, disfigured, or dead. When the People finally tired of their collective oppression, there were certain groups we could do without. We executed all the slumlords in one day when housing was made a public right. It was televised, and most people cheered as the slumlords were led to stand on chairs with their necks tied. They cheered even louder when the chairs were kicked away from under these traitors to humanity. I attended these celebrations with my family, and I knew they were only the beginning.

But we still need the industrialists. For now. And that is why I carry a gun. It’s a standard issue weapon from the Peoples’ Armory, in case the reactionaries attempt my assassination.

On the whole, the revolution was far less violent than the last four hundred years of capitalism were. There was no genocide or slavery involved. We simply redistributed wealth and reorganized production along more rational lines to satisfy need and optimal contribution based on ability. A lot of people thought things would get better because you-know-who was out of office. And things did get a little better. But the country remained racist and patriarchal. It wasn’t long before people remembered that most of the problems that concerned them were only exacerbated from the top for four years. That you-know-who didn’t invent these problems. He was merely a manifestation of capitalism’s acceleration toward its own destruction. The liberal establishment assumed a return to normalcy would be greeted with near universal welcome by “progressives,” but a lot of the people who they dismissively lumped together as “progressives,” without the man at the top to blame, remembered that they hadn’t much love for the old status quo, either. And why should they? It was unequal, and that kind of social stratification was violent in itself. That violence breeds more violence until the system destroys itself and the People organize, bottom-up, grassroots style, to replace it with something better. And that’s exactly what happened. Twenty years ago, people like me were warning everyone else it would happen. And we got treated like Cassandra in the story of the Trojan Horse. It was the same with the Christian Right. I was calling them fascists before it was acceptable, socially, to call them fascists. I used to tell my friends, who didn’t know why I bothered, that I was afraid. That if these people didn’t believe in evidence-based public policy when it came to teaching kids about science or safe sex, that we’d be totally fucking screwed if there was ever a pandemic.

Then, there was a pandemic, and all the people who refused to believe in evolution or evidence-based sex ed, or climate change, unsurprisingly also refused to wear masks and practice social distancing. If I could see this in 2008, what was everyone else’s excuse?

Look, there’s reasons people like me have guns. There are reasons people like Floyd have to do what I say. Unless they want to walk away and forget it. They could. They could just enjoy themselves. They don’t have to take this seriously anymore. It’s really not that important. It’s not even about money. We don’t use money now. It’s just about their fucking egos. All they have left are their names, and in a generation or two, we will just rename things. A rose, by any other name, would smell just as sweet, yes?

I haven’t had to use the gun, yet. Hopefully, I never will. Hopefully, the element I oversee will come to appreciate that cooperation is in their best interest. We have no desire to make of them slaves. We merely wish to eliminate their unique set of socioeconomic privileges. Not by taking away rights, but by expanding them beyond their set. And we nearly have. Their estates were confiscated, and they were allocated spacious and comfortable houses and apartments. They were given choice when we relocated them to make more efficient use of the resources they had hoarded in their heavily guarded compounds. The grounds that once filled in the borders of their extended egos now see more practical use. Their mansions were converted into public housing. Their cars, high-end and hard to maintain symbols of status, were stripped down to their most useful components and recycled into more productive machinery. Their private armies have been disbanded. The police that once protected their property rights have been abolished and replaced by a different kind of police, no longer conflicted by the equation of life and property. Their vast collections of art and artifacts have been relocated across the continent to museums and libraries, where they can be appreciated without special access. They have been reclaimed by the People. Culture has been reclaimed. The libraries and community centers are re-opening. People are taking pride now, in themselves, in a way they couldn’t before, when they were forced into a high-stakes, daily game of quotidian survival.

The People have education, now. They have roofs over their heads. They no longer must choose between spiritual and material struggle. Not a single house of worship has been shuttered by the new government, but freely, most of us have chosen to leave the trappings of religion for the progress of a science and industry no longer shackled to the interests of class enemies. Rival nations- warmongering oligarchies like the Russian Federation and the Corporate Republic of China- call us a slave-state. They claim we know not liberty nor freedom. But their concept of what these things are is rooted in the value system of the people we no longer permit to lead us, morally, or through official means. We deny them the authority they enjoyed. Those were the individuals that nearly destroyed this country. It was we, the People, who saved it.

My son, my daughter, once rejected, impoverished, are freer today than they have ever been. They are students and workers, and no one can tell them they do not deserve their education, their health, and their homes. No one can tell them they did not work hard enough, or otherwise they would know success. They know very well that is possible to do everything the right way and still fail. At least, it used to be. Under the old system, that was the rule, and success was the exception. Now, we build success up from the ground.

My children could never understand the hell I crawled out from, that hateful fire of dismissal and willing ignorance that threatened to consume all life in the name of property, before we organized, and changed everything.

 No industrialist has been jailed simply for being rich. They are no longer rich, but they are still free. They have all the same rights as other workers. The only reason to punish them would be if they continue to do harm. They are free to do other things, if they should wish it. They could walk away from all this. Retire unto themselves. Some have done so. I admire them, as I admire the ones who haven’t, who still come to this office, to face me every day, sitting in their old seats, or standing, like this one, while my one hand grips the butt of my gun, the other opens a thick volume to a middle page on my desk. The book and the gun are both implied threats. No longer content to shame ourselves into pacifistic submission, no longer willing to simply accept our material conditions and resign hope to some intangible faith, we now meet their force with righteous force.

I long for the day when we Liaisons can leave the running of the factories to the unarmed. But there is still much work to do: dissuasion, discouragement, disenfranchisement. These are neither sins nor virtues. They are simply steps in a plan. There is an end in sight, and that end is freedom. It is liberty. It is equality, without contradiction or sacrifice. Without caveats, or terms, or hidden clauses, or very small fonts. This is the thing we fought for- the right to build for ourselves. If these former barons must live in fear for the rest of their lives, it is enough, that their children, and our children, will never know disparity again. They will not grow up to resent each other for being born into stratification. Never again, will they suffer, isolated, in their ivory towers, the cannibalistic impulses of their aggressive minds devouring themselves and each other for sustenance. They are free to wonder, imagine, and think. They can move, dance, pray, or conduct experiments. No one will stop them. We simply do not allow them to profit anymore. It is the People that profit. Wealth that is not shared, is hoarded. When the new government came to power, we sent our military forces out to all the offshore tax shelters we knew about, and we took back the wealth they stole. We didn’t make a lot of friends. But we are stronger, now, and we have justice.

Still, I have a job to do. The fight is not completely won. Sometimes, we find things, the old guard has tried to hide from us. Like this factory in Mexico that’s not in any of the books.

“Look, we gave you a chance to come clean ten years ago. You were supposed to transfer all production back into the country. Give the jobs back. Raise your workers’ standard of living. You told us you did. You signed an oath. Now we find out you’ve been hiding this little operation from us. What’re you paying those Mexican workers? Are you even paying them?”

“The Neveras Plant is not your concern. We have a contract…”

“The Peoples’ State of Mexico declared your contract null and void when they nationalized your partners. Now, they’re part of the PSNA, too. You’re no longer dealing with another country. They found out, so we found out, and now, it has to stop. So, you can shut it down yourself, or I will shut it down for you. You don’t get to exploit people anymore. You don’t get to pursue ever cheaper labor until you’ve reinvented slavery. We don’t let you do that anymore. Never again, Floyd.”

“No,” said Floyd. “It’s you who exploit them. You exploit what you did not invent and cannot reproduce without people like me.”

I shook my head. He still didn’t understand. Not everyone thought like him. There were enough who believed in the public good that we could replace people like him, if we needed to. It wasn’t our first choice, and that’s why I was assigned here, to encourage their cooperation. But we had other means. And we weren’t afraid to use them against the last bourgeois remnant.

This naked gun of mine- an expression of force purer, less convoluted than the old way of money- was still cold. This office- one of many. I walk through the halls of all the tech giants, and inhabit offices like these, with a shiny leather briefcase ominously snapping against my starched, militaristic trousers, my uniform-like dull green shirt with enough open buttons to display coiled black chest hairs. The clothes were a reminder that I was not one of them. That I was here to make sure they played along. They still went through the motions of things the old way. They wore their suits and ties and drove cars they thought made them respectable, but the bitter resentment against them that launched the revolution was only spreading.

I jam the gun in his face, and I lick my lips in a theatrical display of menace, calculating fear.

“Would you rather be ugly or dead?” I ask him.

“Huh?”

“Theoretical question. Ugly? Or dead? Since you don’t seem to not want me to shoot you. Otherwise you’d cooperate with the new economic program. You wouldn’t be finding loopholes or hiding shit under the carpet. You would’ve been honest, and we wouldn’t be having this conversation. Do you think I like this? Man, people like you really piss me off. Your problem is you refuse to take accountability. You were warned. Many, many times. And you didn’t listen. Face it man. Class war’s over. Your side lost. But I’d still really like to treat you like a human being and a willing partner in the uplift of all of us. I just wish you could see that. I wish you understood you could be part of this.”

“Who made you so hateful?” Floyd asks me contemptuously. I resent the implication that it was I who had a problem. So, I don’t answer.

“What made you so selfish?” I ask him.

“It’s not ‘selfish,’” he says. “It’s self-interest. That’s different.”

“Not different enough,” I say. “Not enough to matter. Floyd… go home, okay? Take a rest week. Then, come back and tell me if you still want to fight this. And if you do, you can lodge a complaint. But don’t go all hyperbolic and accuse us of reinventing slavery. It’s intellectually dishonest and it’s insulting to actual slaves and their descendants. That includes all the people still held in actual fucking slavery in the capitalist world. So, don’t ever let me hear you say that word again, you insincere and spoiled little motherfucker. You’ve violated our labor codes and I’ve caught you. I’ve chosen to deal with you myself rather than report you to someone who doesn’t know you and doesn’t appreciate your work. Please, cooperate with me.”

He had to cooperate! His company was nationalized. It was our business if he was outsourcing labor to a sweatshop. Humanity was our business.

“Floyd, under the terms of the new system, you’re not allowed to do this. It’s wrong and inhumane and you know it.”

“Well, you like your phone, don’t you? You like video-calling your kids in Philly? You like browsing FaceWeb on your break? You like the touchscreen and the MeTube app and the alarm that reminds you about Mother’s Day?”

I take my phone out of my pocket and hold it up to him, the screen facing him.

“Yeah, but I don’t love my phone,” I say. I throw it forcefully on the ground and the screen, satisfyingly, cracks. Things can be replaced.

How could any human being think a fucking smart phone was worth sweat shops?

I pick up the now-broken phone and I hold it out for Floyd like I want him to take it from my hand.

“Here. You can have your phone back,” I say.

He looks at me with his jaw hanging slightly open, like a question is frozen on his face. But unless he asks it, directly, I have no intent to answer.

I already know what it’s likely to be.

He still wants to know what makes me so hateful.

He just doesn’t get it, and maybe he will, one day, and maybe he won’t. That’s not my problem. I’m not social services. It’s not my job to morally rehabilitate the old ruling class. It’s my job to find out about things like sweatshops being run in our own midst. It’s my job to shut them down. I offered to do this quietly, so it didn’t hurt Floyd. But Floyd couldn’t see the logic in this proposal. He must have been pocketing foreign money. Someone bribed him. That was enough. That was all it took. The promise of more than he needed. What a shallow, despicable man.

“What I hate,” I tell him, in no uncertain terms, “Is when people like you still refuse to learn from the past. We tried things your way, and it was bad for a lot of people. They didn’t like it. So now, things are different. You have to deal with that. You could still walk away. Please, please walk away.”

He says nothing. He considers his life. He turns around. He walks away.

I pull back the slide to dislodge the bullet from the chamber. I eject the clip from the magazine, and I push the bullet back inside.

Not a bullet wasted. The only paperwork I’ll have to do is the retirement slip. This was a victory. Not having to hurt him. To make him comply.

One day there won’t be a need for men like me. We can be recycled, too.

 

 

The Lesson of 2024 (political post)

Last week, the Democratic Party enjoyed a blue wave. Democrats now control both houses and have the majority of governors. Was this an endor...